Dark Delirium: The Pagan North Series
Part Two
Picture this: you’re at a village fête, somewhere in the Cotswolds, watching Morris dancers leap about with bells jangling while the vicar blesses the maypole. Someone inevitably pipes up with, “Ah, good old English Christian tradition!” But here’s the thing — and do sit down for this — those Morris dancers are essentially performing pagan fertility rituals whilst the good reverend is sanctifying what amounts to a giant fertility symbol. Rather puts a spanner in the works of the “always been a Christian nation” narrative, doesn’t it?
We’re told Britain has been a bastion of Christianity since time immemorial, but the historical evidence suggests our ancestors were rather more… creative with their spiritual arrangements. Think of it less as a clean conversion story and more like a messy flatshare where the new tenants never quite managed to evict all the previous occupants.
When Britain Was Gloriously, Unapologetically Pagan
Before we had parish churches, we had sacred groves. Before hymns, we had druids chanting at stone circles that make Stonehenge look like a garden ornament. Celtic Britain was absolutely teeming with spirits, gods, and magical thinking that would make a modern festival-goer weep with envy.
The Celts saw divinity everywhere — in every babbling brook, gnarled oak, and suspiciously shaped hill. They had gods for everything: war, harvest, the art of metalworking, and presumably one for that peculiar British obsession with discussing the weather. Rivers were goddesses, springs were sacred, and if you wanted divine intervention, you popped down to the local holy well with an offering rather than lighting a candle in church.
Then along came the Anglo-Saxons in the 5th century, bringing their own delightful pantheon. Woden, Thunor, Frig — names that survive in our days of the week, because apparently even after converting to Christianity, we couldn’t quite bring ourselves to give up Tuesday being named after a war god.
Rome’s Rather Half-Hearted Christian Makeover
Christianity did arrive with the Romans, sometime between the 2nd and 4th centuries, but it was rather like a dinner party where only the posh guests bothered to show up. Urban elites and a smattering of Romans adopted the new faith, while the vast majority of Britons continued happily sacrificing to their local deities and reading omens in sheep’s entrails.
When Rome packed up and left in 410 CE (the original Brexit, you might say), most of this fledgling Christian infrastructure collapsed faster than a poorly constructed Roman villa. The countryside, which had barely been touched by Christianity anyway, cheerfully reverted to its pagan ways. It’s rather telling that archaeological evidence from the 5th and 6th centuries shows a resurgence of pagan burial practices and ritual deposits at sacred sites.
The Great Christian Sales Pitch
Enter Augustine of Canterbury in 597 CE, armed with papal authority and what can only be described as the medieval equivalent of a corporate takeover strategy. Pope Gregory’s plan was brilliantly cynical: convert the kings first, and their subjects would follow like sheep. No need for genuine spiritual awakening among the masses — just get the bloke with the biggest sword on side.
And it worked, sort of. Kings found Christianity rather useful for diplomatic relations with Continental Europe and impressive stone churches were excellent for showing off to visiting dignitaries. But let’s not mistake political expedience for spiritual revolution. Many early “conversions” were about as genuine as a politician’s campaign promise.
The Awkward Matter of Pagan Resistance
Not everyone was terribly impressed with this new monotheistic arrangement. King Penda of Mercia, remained staunchly pagan well into the 7th century and spent considerable energy making Christian kings rather deceased. The poor chap fought bloody wars against the likes of Oswald of Northumbria, proving that religious conversion was far from the peaceful, inevitable process our history books suggest.
Some rulers paid the ultimate price for their theological stubbornness….like Arwald of the Isle of Wight was killed in 686 CE, partly for the inconvenient matter of refusing baptism.
The Peasants’ Inconvenient Memory
Here’s where things get deliciously awkward for the official narrative. Even after kingdoms had officially “converted,” the common folk displayed an alarming tendency to keep practicing what Christian authorities sniffily called “pagan superstitions.”
For centuries — centuries! — priests complained about their flocks persisting with charms, spells, seasonal festivals, and offerings at wells and sacred trees. Archaeological evidence shows people continued leaving votive offerings at pagan sites well into the medieval period. It’s rather like announcing your house is now vegetarian while the sausages continue sizzling in the back garden.
The Church’s response was pragmatc, if not entirely honest: if you can’t beat them, absorb them. They turned pagan festivals into Christian holidays (Yule became Christmas, Eostre became Easter), sacred wells became holy wells associated with Christian saints, and local deities were rebranded as saints with remarkably similar portfolios.
Christianity’s Rather Pagan Wardrobe
This absorption process created something that would have horrified the early Christian fathers: a thoroughly hybridized faith that was about as purely Christian as a Sunday roast is purely vegetarian.
Take Christmas, for instance. The date, the evergreen decorations, the feast, the gift-giving — all borrowed from winter solstice celebrations. Easter? Named after a Germanic fertility goddess, complete with eggs and rabbits (hardly subtle fertility symbols). Even many British saints look suspiciously like recycled pagan deities with hastily added hagiographies.
It’s rather like claiming your house is authentically Victorian when you’ve simply draped Union Jack bunting over a medieval timber frame.
The Propaganda Problem
Much of our “always been Christian” narrative comes from sources like Bede, who was essentially writing the medieval equivalent of corporate PR. His “Ecclesiastical History” presents conversion as inevitable, divinely guided, and largely peaceful — which is rather like asking a estate agent to provide an objective assessment of the housing market.
These clerical chroniclers had every reason to present Christianity’s triumph as preordained and complete. Admitting that large swathes of the population remained stubbornly attached to their ancestral beliefs would have been rather embarrassing for the Church’s claims of universal authority.
The Inconvenient Truth
Here’s the mathematical reality that rather spoils the party: Britain was pagan for approximately 6,000 years and has been officially Christian for about 1,400 years. Even if we accept the most generous interpretation of “Christian conversion” (which involves considerable creative accounting), paganism had a much longer lease on the property.
And those pagan roots? They never really died. They simply went underground, surfaced in folk customs, seasonal celebrations, and that peculiarly British tendency to touch wood, throw salt over shoulders, and maintain elaborate superstitions about magpies.
So, Was Britain Ever Truly Christian?
The honest answer is rather more complicated than the Sunday school version suggests. Britain became officially Christian through a combination of political convenience, cultural absorption, and the occasional pointed sword. But underneath the veneer of crosses and cathedral spires, the old ways persisted with remarkable tenacity.
Modern Britain is still performing this ancient dance between Christian orthodoxy and pagan instinct. We sing hymns on Sunday and read horoscopes on Monday. We celebrate Christmas with trees and Easter with eggs, blissfully unaware we’re participating in festivals that would be quite familiar to a Bronze Age Briton.
Perhaps the question isn’t whether Britain was ever truly Christian, but whether it ever stopped being fundamentally pagan. After all, when your “Christian” festivals revolve around solstices and fertility symbols, when your “Christian” holy sites are built on ancient sacred grounds, and when your “Christian” saints suspiciously resemble local deities — well, it rather suggests the old gods simply learned to wear crosses.
The truth is, Britain’s spiritual identity is rather like its weather: complex, changeable, and utterly resistant to simple categorization. We’re a nation that managed to be pagan and Christian simultaneously for over a millennium, which is possibly the most British approach to religion imaginable — why choose one when you can have both, with a nice cup of tea on the side?
Please subscribe….its free!